Buy Plush Toys for Cats in Pagosa Springs

The Best Array of Cat Plush Toys. In-Store Pickup, Curbside Pickup, Local Delivery, Same Day Delivery, No Contact Delivery.

Support Our Local Pet Store with Your Order of Plush Toys for Cats

Cats love toys. If you were to close your eyes and reflect on your happiest times with your cat, chances are that the images that come to mind are your cat(s) playing. Hunting, attacking, overpowering, and hitting toys around gives cats and their people tons of joy - so why do cats so often ignore the toys we bring home for them?

There is one very straightforward rule to remember when buying toys for cats: cats like a variety of toys. They like an assortment of interactive cat toys that use all of their hunting skills. If you have enough toys, you can rotate your cat's choices so they can search for a preferred toy. Just don't hide a favorite toy away forever. Ensure your cats have opportunities to play with all of their toys often.

What are the groups of cat toys? Here are just a few:

Balls and chasers entice your cat to chase with feathers, fun noises, and uncommon shapes.

Chew toys are a great option for cats that love to chew. They also help to keep your cat's breath fresh and their teeth clean.

Interactive and electronic toys bring out the best in your cat's hunting skills.

Plush and mice toys eventually are beloved toys that can soothe and ease your cat when it's time to go into the carrier.

Scratcher posts and mats are a must for all ages of cats, from kitties to more mature cats.

Teasers and wands are great toys for sharing playtime with your cat.

Tunnels become the hiding places where you can easily find your cat.

And variety packs help ensure your cat always has a fun toy.

Cats favor toys that are light and small enough to be swatted without a lot of effort. They also like toys that are small enough to be grasped. And their favorite toys are objects they can interact with in multiple different ways.

When you are searching for toys for your cat, you need to make sure they don't have any strings that could be pulled off and ingested. They need to be large enough that your cat won't try to eat them. They need to be made from non-toxic materials. Tiny button eyes and button noses are adorable, but anything that can be bitten off and swallowed is hazardous for your cat. Cats of all ages can be injured by toys with sharp points and edges. At Chow Down Pet Supplies, we only supply toys that are safe for your cat.

You will find the toys your cat will love at Chow Down Pet Supplies in Pagosa Springs, CO. We have an assortment of toys to thrill every cat at prices that will excite you. Stop by today or call us with any questions.

Read Why Pet Parents Love Us

View our recent reviews from customers throughout Montrose, Fruita, Evergreen, Grand JunctionPagosa Springs, Delta, and surrounding areas!

😂🤪😂 the cat loves the home grown Cat Nip !! Her cat howls are wild ⚡️
WhiteRice Cowboy

2025-10-21

We went here while on a road trip because our cats weren't eating. We got great help picking out some delicious kitty kibble. The man who helped us even gave us a free sample of it to make sure our cats liked it before we purchased it. Turns out they loved it and our kitties were happy and eating again. They also had cute shop cats, especially mouse. It seems like the people who work here, it's more than just a job for them and they really love animals.

Sarah MacKenzie

2025-10-16

My grandson adopted his first kitten from the Humane Society. He was given a folder with a voucher from Chow Down. He received so many goodies; treats, food and litter! Chow Down was such a blessing to him and his new kitten! They were very helpful in letting him know what foods to pick and other helpful hints. We will certainly be back for other cat needs!

Darlene Dorries

2025-09-26

Come visit our pet supply store in Pagosa Springs, CO specializing in quality food, treats, and supplies for cats and dogs.